It’s one of the hardest-working staples in your summer wardrobe. It can be both underwear or a plain top. It’s the layer you throw on after the beach, under an open camp shirt or with a pair of easy drawstring pants when it’s simply too hot to think about getting dressed properly. Sure, the style spent years carrying a slightly “dirt bag” reputation. You’ve no doubt heard them referred to by their domestic violence-influenced nickname—but it’s been rebranded these days as the more palatable “wife pleasers.”

The difference now is all in the fit and fabric. The best ribbed tanks feel soft but substantial, with a closer fit through the body that still hangs cleanly under shirts, knit polos and even lightweight jackets. A good one should look intentional on its own, and right now, brands are finally getting the fabrics and proportions perfected with just enough structure to feel modern. We tried on dozens to bring you the best ones for your money.