A couple summers ago, fisherman sandals still felt a little risky, right? Maybe a touch too fashion-y. A tad too Euro vacation. Perhaps you told yourself “I’m not some guy who owns linen drawstring pants.” But now? They’ve settled into that sweet spot where the trend has cooled off just enough to become genuinely wearable. The appeal is obvious: they’re more polished than flip-flops, more breathable than loafers and somehow manage to look both vintage and modern at the same time.

The key is finding the right balance. The best fisherman sandals feel substantial without getting clunky, with enough structure to work with trousers and enough openness to still feel easy in hot weather. At the lower end, you’re getting trend-forward style at an approachable price. Spend more and the leather improves, while the construction gets sturdier and the silhouette sharpens up considerably. Here are some of the best options at every level.